NPDB Questions and Answers from the Conference:
Question 1:
An advanced practice registered nurse (APRN) is applying for a position at a hospital. Does the hospital have to query the NPDB on the nurse?
Answer:
It depends. If the hospital considers the position the APRN is applying for to be on the hospital’s medical staff, or if the APRN will hold clinical privileges at the hospital, the hospital must query on the APRN when the APRN applies and biennially thereafter while the APRN is on staff or holds privileges. If the hospital does not consider the position to be on the medical staff or if the APRN will not hold clinical privileges, the hospital is not required to query on the APRN. It may do so if it desires, however.
Question 2:
Under what conditions are hospitals required to query every 2 years on courtesy staff who are afforded only non-clinical professional privileges?
Answer:
Hospitals are required to query on courtesy staff considered part of the medical staff, even if afforded only non-clinical professional courtesies such as use of the medical library and continuing education facilities. If a hospital extends non-clinical practice courtesies without first appointing practitioners to a medical staff category, querying is not required on those practitioners.
Clinical Privileges Actions
Question 3:
A physician applied to a hospital for clinical privileges to perform cardiac procedures. The hospital requires that such applications be granted only if the applying physician has performed 50 cardiac procedures in the previous year. The applying physician has performed only 40 such procedures. The hospital denies the application based solely on the physician not having met its 50-procedure requirement. Should this denial be reported to the NPDB?
Answer 3:
No. A denial of clinical privileges that occurs solely because a practitioner does not meet a health care institution’s established threshold criteria for that particular privilege should not be reported to the NPDB. Such denials are not considered to be the result of a professional review action relating to the practitioner’s professional competence or professional conduct but, rather, are considered to be decisions based on eligibility that are not reportable.
Question 4:
When a physician surrenders medical staff privileges due to personal reasons, infirmity, or retirement, and such a surrender did not occur in order to avoid an investigation or during an investigation, should it be reported to the NPDB?
Answer 4:
No. The surrender not should not be reported to the NPDB because the physician did not surrender his clinical privileges while under investigation by a health care entity relating to possible professional incompetence or improper professional conduct, or in return for not conducting such an investigation.
However, if an investigation was under way when the physician surrendered his privileges, even if the physician was not aware of the investigation, the surrender would have to be reported even if the physician claimed he surrendered the privileges for unrelated personal reasons.
Question 5:
Based on assessment of professional competence and as a result of a professional review action, a proctor is assigned to watch a physician’s or dentist’s procedures for a period of more than 30 days, and the proctor needs to be present or grant approval before medical care is provided by the practitioner. Is this reportable to the NPDB?
Answer 5:
Yes. If, for a period lasting more than 30 days, the physician or dentist cannot perform certain procedures without proctor approval or without the proctor being present and watching the physician or dentist, the action constitutes a restriction of clinical privileges and must be reported to the NPDB. However, if the proctor is not required to be present for or approve the procedures (for example, the proctoring consists of the proctor reviewing the physician's or dentist's records or procedures after they occur), the action is not considered a restriction of clinical privileges and should not be reported to the NPDB.
Question 6:
A hospital initiated an investigation related to the professional conduct of a physician who held time-limited, nonrenewable, temporary privileges at the hospital. During the investigation, the physician’s temporary privileges expired and the hospital took no further action. Should this be reported?
Answer 6:
No. Generally, the NPDB makes no distinction between adverse actions taken with respect to temporary or permanent privileges. However, in this case, there was no resignation of privileges while under investigation because the temporary privileges expired and the physician could not renew them. This is unlike the typical situation where regular privileges that could be renewed expire during an investigation. In a situation such as that, an action to not renew permanent clinical privileges while under investigation for issues related to professional competence or conduct is considered a resignation while under investigation and should be reported.
Question 7:
A hospital summarily suspended a physician's clinical privileges to allow sufficient time for allegations of gross negligence to be fully investigated. The day after the summary suspension was imposed, the physician requested an educational leave of absence. If the hospital grants the leave of absence, must the summary suspension be reported to the NPDB?
Answer 7:
It depends. If the summary suspension is not lifted within 30 days, it must be reported to the NPDB, regardless of when the leave of absence begins or if it ever occurs.
Question 8:
A hospital automatically revoked a physician's clinical privileges when the physician lost her license. Should this action be reported?
Answer 8:
No. Administrative actions that do not involve a professional review action should not be reported to the NPDB. The revocation of clinical privileges is automatic because the practitioner no longer holds a license. Regardless of the reason for the State medical board's licensure action, the hospital's revocation of privileges was not the result of a professional review action. Therefore, the hospital's action should not be reported to the NPDB.
Question 9:
A hospital suspended a physician's clinical privileges for 45 days for failing to complete medical records. Should this action be reported to the NPDB?
Answer 9:
It Depends.
Such a suspension must be reported to the NPDB if:
the suspension is a result of a professional review action;
the hospital determines that the failure to complete medical records is related to the physician's professional competence or conduct; and
the hospital determines the failure to complete medical records adversely affects or could adversely affect a patient's health or welfare.
If the suspension of the practitioner's clinical privileges is the result of an automatic or administrative action, and not the result of a professional review action, the suspension should not be reported to the NPDB.
2 Comments
Jamila Johnson
Nov. 23, 2021
NPDB Questions and Answers from the Conference: Question 1: An advanced practice registered nurse (APRN) is applying for a position at a hospital. Does the hospital have to query the NPDB on the nurse? Answer: It depends. If the hospital considers the position the APRN is applying for to be on the hospital’s medical staff, or if the APRN will hold clinical privileges at the hospital, the hospital must query on the APRN when the APRN applies and biennially thereafter while the APRN is on staff or holds privileges. If the hospital does not consider the position to be on the medical staff or if the APRN will not hold clinical privileges, the hospital is not required to query on the APRN. It may do so if it desires, however. Question 2: Under what conditions are hospitals required to query every 2 years on courtesy staff who are afforded only non-clinical professional privileges? Answer: Hospitals are required to query on courtesy staff considered part of the medical staff, even if afforded only non-clinical professional courtesies such as use of the medical library and continuing education facilities. If a hospital extends non-clinical practice courtesies without first appointing practitioners to a medical staff category, querying is not required on those practitioners. Clinical Privileges Actions Question 3: A physician applied to a hospital for clinical privileges to perform cardiac procedures. The hospital requires that such applications be granted only if the applying physician has performed 50 cardiac procedures in the previous year. The applying physician has performed only 40 such procedures. The hospital denies the application based solely on the physician not having met its 50-procedure requirement. Should this denial be reported to the NPDB? Answer 3: No. A denial of clinical privileges that occurs solely because a practitioner does not meet a health care institution’s established threshold criteria for that particular privilege should not be reported to the NPDB. Such denials are not considered to be the result of a professional review action relating to the practitioner’s professional competence or professional conduct but, rather, are considered to be decisions based on eligibility that are not reportable. Question 4: When a physician surrenders medical staff privileges due to personal reasons, infirmity, or retirement, and such a surrender did not occur in order to avoid an investigation or during an investigation, should it be reported to the NPDB? Answer 4: No. The surrender not should not be reported to the NPDB because the physician did not surrender his clinical privileges while under investigation by a health care entity relating to possible professional incompetence or improper professional conduct, or in return for not conducting such an investigation. However, if an investigation was under way when the physician surrendered his privileges, even if the physician was not aware of the investigation, the surrender would have to be reported even if the physician claimed he surrendered the privileges for unrelated personal reasons. Question 5: Based on assessment of professional competence and as a result of a professional review action, a proctor is assigned to watch a physician’s or dentist’s procedures for a period of more than 30 days, and the proctor needs to be present or grant approval before medical care is provided by the practitioner. Is this reportable to the NPDB? Answer 5: Yes. If, for a period lasting more than 30 days, the physician or dentist cannot perform certain procedures without proctor approval or without the proctor being present and watching the physician or dentist, the action constitutes a restriction of clinical privileges and must be reported to the NPDB. However, if the proctor is not required to be present for or approve the procedures (for example, the proctoring consists of the proctor reviewing the physician's or dentist's records or procedures after they occur), the action is not considered a restriction of clinical privileges and should not be reported to the NPDB. Question 6: A hospital initiated an investigation related to the professional conduct of a physician who held time-limited, nonrenewable, temporary privileges at the hospital. During the investigation, the physician’s temporary privileges expired and the hospital took no further action. Should this be reported? Answer 6: No. Generally, the NPDB makes no distinction between adverse actions taken with respect to temporary or permanent privileges. However, in this case, there was no resignation of privileges while under investigation because the temporary privileges expired and the physician could not renew them. This is unlike the typical situation where regular privileges that could be renewed expire during an investigation. In a situation such as that, an action to not renew permanent clinical privileges while under investigation for issues related to professional competence or conduct is considered a resignation while under investigation and should be reported. Question 7: A hospital summarily suspended a physician's clinical privileges to allow sufficient time for allegations of gross negligence to be fully investigated. The day after the summary suspension was imposed, the physician requested an educational leave of absence. If the hospital grants the leave of absence, must the summary suspension be reported to the NPDB? Answer 7: It depends. If the summary suspension is not lifted within 30 days, it must be reported to the NPDB, regardless of when the leave of absence begins or if it ever occurs. Question 8: A hospital automatically revoked a physician's clinical privileges when the physician lost her license. Should this action be reported? Answer 8: No. Administrative actions that do not involve a professional review action should not be reported to the NPDB. The revocation of clinical privileges is automatic because the practitioner no longer holds a license. Regardless of the reason for the State medical board's licensure action, the hospital's revocation of privileges was not the result of a professional review action. Therefore, the hospital's action should not be reported to the NPDB. Question 9: A hospital suspended a physician's clinical privileges for 45 days for failing to complete medical records. Should this action be reported to the NPDB? Answer 9: It Depends. Such a suspension must be reported to the NPDB if: the suspension is a result of a professional review action; the hospital determines that the failure to complete medical records is related to the physician's professional competence or conduct; and the hospital determines the failure to complete medical records adversely affects or could adversely affect a patient's health or welfare. If the suspension of the practitioner's clinical privileges is the result of an automatic or administrative action, and not the result of a professional review action, the suspension should not be reported to the NPDB.
ReplyJamila Johnson
Nov. 11, 2021
It was enlightening to find out the NPDB reps can possibly call out hospitals for failing to report that was discoverable by way of the news.
Reply